Knowledge of the morphology of initial chambers and early ontogenetic characters is of key importance for the understanding of phylogenetic pathways and affinities of individual Cephalopod groups. However, the embryonic development is insufficiently known in some important groups. This is particularly the case in the phylogenetically earliest (Early and Middle Ordovician) Orthoceratoids, a group from which the Bactritoids, Ammonoids, and Coleoids originated. In fact, only a handful of specimens representing apical-most parts of Orthoceratoid phragmocones are known. Stratigraphically earliest are Bactroceras angustisiphonatum, from the uppermost Floian–lowermost Dapingian stages of Svalbard, and Arionoceras? sp., from the Floian? Stage of Peru. Stratigraphically younger are the Darriwilian Bactroceras sandbergeri, from the Prague Basin, Central Bohemia, Orthoceras sp., from the Kunda region of Estonia and Archigeisonoceras sp., from the Swedish island of Öland.
In a paper published in the journal Acta Palaeontologica Polonica on 14 May 2020, Martina Aubrechtová of the Institute of Geology and Palaeontology at the University in Prague, Vojtěch Turek of the National Museum Prague, and Ondřej Zicha of BioLib significantly expand the above records by describing 18 more apices of Middle Ordovician Orthoceratoids.
Two of the new specimens were identified in the historical collections of the National Museum in Prague; the remainder of the material was recently collected by Ondřej Zicha, from an area around the city of Rokycany in the Plzeň Region of Western Bohemia, and the territories of Beroun and Prague.
Aubrechtová et al. compare the morphology of the Bohemian specimens with that of other known Ordovician Orthoceratoid apices from elsewhere and discuss their relevance for reconstructing reproductive strategies in early Paleozoic Orthoceratoids.
The specimens originate from the early–mid Darriwilian Šárka Formation and the late Darriwilian part of the Dobrotivá Formation of the Prague Basin.
Eighteen specimens were investigated in this study, sixteen of which originate from the Šárka Formation. NM L 46566 was collected by František Hanuš in the 1930’s at the locality of Praha-Šárka cihelna (brickyard). NM L 46565 originates from the collection of Celda Klouček from the locality of Praha-Šárka. The remaining specimens were recently collected by Ondřej Zicha in the area of the city of Rokycany at the following localities: Mýto (Svatoštěpánský rybník-Teletník; MWB S 06761, 06765), Mýto (Svatoštěpánský rybník-Kařízek; MWB S 06762), Rokycany-Díly (MWB S 06759, 06763), Těškov (MWB S 06760, 06764), and Volduchy (MWB S 06823–06828); one specimen comes from the locality of Praha-Hanspaulka NM L 59577).
Two specimens from the Dobrotivá Formation (NM L 59578, 59872) were found by Ondřej Zicha at localities of Lhotka u Berouna and Malé Přílepy.
All specimens from the Šárka Formation are preserved in 3D in siliceous, originally carbonaceous, nodules. The specimens are mostly preserved as counterparts but internal moulds or their fragments are also present. The specimens are not deformed or recrystallized with the exception of NM L 46566, which is entirely in-filled with brown-orange carbonate crystals. NM L 59578 from the Dobrotivá Formation is preserved 3D in a grey-coloured sandy nodule; NM L 59872 is embedded in a dark-grey silicified nodule.
Measurements were performed using either a handheld calliper or an Olympus SZH10 microscope with an integrated scale (angles of expansion of the shells were not precisely measurable in short fragments). Latex casts were prepared from selected counterparts of specimens. Specimens were coated in ammonium chloride, and photographed with Canon EOS 6D and SONY ILCE-7RM3 digital cameras. The specimen of Bactroceras sandbergeri, NM L 10331, with preserved initial chamber was studied for comparisons.
Thirteen of the new specimens were also referred to the species Bactroceras sandbergeri.
The first of these, MWB S 06759, is a part and counterpart of an embryonic portion of the shell with the initial chamber. The total length of the specimen is 2.7 mm. The subspherical initial chamber (i.e. the first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 2.5 mm in diameter and 0.9 mm in length (shape ratio 0.36). The second phragmocone chamber is 2.1 mm in basal diameter and 1.8 mm in length. The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (constriction ratio 0.84). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The marginal (ventral) siphuncle is weathered out and a cavity is left. The cavity appears at about the mid-length of the initial chamber. The caecum is cylindrical, 0.3 mm in diameter; its apical end clearly bends towards the inside of the initial chamber at about its mid-length. The external surface as shown by the latex cast of the counterpart is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by another Orthoceratoid shell ornamented with transverse lirae, an indeterminate Hyolith, the Trilobite Ormathops and the Brachiopod Euorthisina sp
The second specimen, MWB S 06760, is a counterpart of a shell and the third septum of the phragmocone showing the position of the siphuncle. The specimen shows an imprint of the initial chamber. The total length of the specimen is 5.2 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) was bean- shaped in median section, 2.5 mm in diameter and 1.2 mm in length (shape ratio 0.48). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2.2 mm, constriction ratio 0.88). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The specimen is accompanied by the Hyolith Bactrotheca teres and other indeterminate invertebrate fragments.
The third specimen, MWB S 06761, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell. The total length of the specimen is 13.1 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 2.2 mm in diameter and 1.1 mm in length (shape ratio 0.5). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2 mm, constriction ratio 0.91). The phragmocone has a maximum diameter of 2.5 mm and expands very slowly (angle of expansion 2°). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The external surface is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by a Hyolith and other indeterminate invertebrate fragments.
The fourth specimen, MWB S 06762, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell. The total length of the specimen is 20 mm. The initial chamber is bean-shaped in median section, 2.5 mm in diameter and 1.6 mm in length (shape ratio 0.64). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2.3 mm, constriction ratio 0.92). The phragmocone expands very slowly. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The external surface is smooth.
The fifth specimen, MWB S 06763, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell with one phragmocone chamber preserved adorally. The total length of the specimen is 10.4 mm. The initial chamber is bean-shaped in median section, 2 mm in dorso-ventral diameter and 1.3 mm in length (shape ratio 0.65). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 1.8 mm, constriction ratio 0.9). The phragmocone has a maximum dorso-ventral diameter of 2.3 mm and expands very slowly. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The septum of the adoralmost phragmocone chamber displays the submarginal (subventral) siphuncle, which has a circular cross-section and a diameter of 0.25 mm. The external shell surface is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus, the Trilobite Pricyclopyge cf. binodosa and an indeterminate Bivalve.
The sixth specimen, MWB S 06764, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell with one phragmocone chamber preserved adorally. The total length of the specimen is 3.5 mm. The initial chamber is bean-shaped in median section, very short, 2.6 mm in dorso-ventral diameter and 1.4 mm in length (shape ratio 0.54). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2.2 mm, constriction ratio 0.85). The phragmocone has a maximum dorso-ventral diameter of 2.2 mm and expands very slowly; it is circular in cross-section. The length of the adoralmost phragmocone chamber is 1.2 mm. The siphuncle is narrow, submarginal (ventral) with a circular cross-section. The external shell surface is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus.
The seventh specimen, NM L 59577, is a counterpart of an embryonic shell with the initial chamber. The adoral part of the shell is very slightly bent. The total length of the specimen 4.5 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 2.0 mm in diameter and 1.2 mm in length (shape ratio 0.6). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 1.7 mm, constriction ratio 0.85). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. No shell ornamentation is discernible. The nodule containing this specimen also yielded the rare Graptolite Dichograptus? leptotheca.
The eigth specimen, MWB S 06823, represents the third phragmocone chamber (estimated based on the shell diameter and length of this chamber) and the adapical part of the living chamber. The phragmocone has a minimum dorsoventral diameter of 1.8 mm, a minimum lateral diameter of 1.6 mm and expands very slowly; it is slightly compressed in cross-section. The length of the third phragmocone chamber is 2.7 mm. The siphuncle is narrow, submarginal (ventral) with a circular cross-section; its diameter at the foramen of the adapical septum is 0.25 mm. The specimen is accompanied by undetermined Hyoliths and the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus.
The three remaining specimens MWB S 06824–06826 from the locality Volduchy are juvenile shell fragments that morphologically correspond to the above described specimens. However, their preservation hinders precise measurements.
MWB S 06759, 06763, and 06764 are shell fragments of larger individuals as indicated by the absence of living chambers. By contrast, specimen MWB S 06823 probably represents the shell of an early juvenile individual. The rest of the specimens (counterparts) do not show any internal structures and therefore can represent both complete shells of freshly hatched individuals, or adapical parts of later growth stages.
The specimens unequivocally belong to Bactroceras sandbergeri because they exhibit short, bean-shaped in median section, rather large and constricted initial chambers. These characters correspond in all aspects to the only apex previously known from the species.The only difference concerns the caecum, which is slightly more curved in MWB S 06759 than in the original specimen.
In Bactroceras the apicalmost chamber is known also in Bactroceras angustisiphonatum, where it is, however, much smaller in size (1.3 mm in height, 1 mm in diameter, shape ratio 1.3), less constricted (constriction ratio 0.95) and more ovoid in shape.
Of all known Ordovician Orthoceratoids, the shape of the initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri is most similar to that of Orthoceras sp. The latter is, however, much smaller in diameter, the caecum is much shorter and the siphuncle has a ventro-central position. Compared to Bactroceras sandbergeri, the initial chamber of Archigeisonoceras sp. is smaller and only very slightly constricted; the caecum is bent inwards and relatively long but expands inside the initial chamber.
One specimen, NM L 59578, is referred to Bactroceras sp., i.e. assigned to the genus Bactroceras, but not a species. This specimen is a fragment of an adapical part of a juvenile phragmocone with visible concave side of one septum. The length of the specimen is 3.5 mm. The phragmocone has a maximum diameter of 2.5 mm and expands at a very low angle (which cannot be precisely measured). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The septal foramina of the single visible septum is circular in cross-section, c. 0.1 mm in diameter and submarginal in position. The external surface of the shell is smooth.
The narrow, submarginal siphuncle of NM L 59578 indicates the specimen should be assigned to the genus Bactroceras. However, the preservation of the specimen does not permit determination to the species level.
NM L 59578 represents the first record of Bactroceras from the late Darriwilian Dobrotivá Formation of the Prague Basin.
Specimen NM L 46566 is considered to have come from an unknown Orthoceratid species, identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1. The specimen is a part and a counterpart of a phragmocone with the initial chamber. Adapical third of the phragmocone is longitudinally broken off and infilled with a brownish carbonate mineral; the broken portion was reconstructed using a latex cast prepared from the counterpart. The total length of the specimen is 46.8 mm. A weakly sinuous line along the contact of the fossil and the surrounding rock indicates the presence of a low annulation on the surface of the shell. The surface is, however, slightly corroded and does not show any other ornamentation. The initial chamber is egg-shaped, very slightly asymmetric from one side, 3 mm in diameter and 3.1 mm in length (shape ratio c. 1). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the adjacent phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 2.6 mm, constriction ratio 0.87). The first, straight and directly transverse, suture is faintly indicated. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section with a maximum diameter of c. 7 mm and expands with an angle of 6°.
The initial chamber of the specimen stands out among other apical shell parts known from Ordovician Orthoceratids in its large size reaching 3 mm in diameter and 3.1 mm in length. It may resemble the initial chamber described in Arionoceras?, which is ovoid in shape; the latter is, however, smaller in dimensions, more distinctly constricted and has a greater angle of expansion (13°).
The Bohemian specimen more likely belongs to one of the Middle Ordovician Orthoceratid species described by Joachim Barrande, in which early ontogenetic stages are not yet known. Unfortunately, the collection of Joachim Barrande contains either fragmentary material, or specimens representing only late ontogenetic stages. Moreover, the preservation of the specimen studied here does not show the character of the siphuncle and ornamentation is only slightly indicated, which prevents the specimen from being more precisely identified.
Another specimen, MWB S 06765, is considered to belong to another unknown species, identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2. This specimen consists of two counterparts of a phragmocone composed of two dislocated fragments. In each of the two counterparts there is one septum preserved. The rest of the shell was reconstructed from a latex cast. Total combined length is 15.3 mm (apical fragment 9.1 mm and adoral fragment 6.2 mm). The initial chamber is eggshaped, 2 mm in dorso-ventral diameter and 2 mm in length (shape ratio 1). Its diameter very slightly exceeds that of the adjacent phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 1.9 mm, constriction 0.95). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The siphuncle is 0.25 mm in diameter (corresponding shell diameter 23 mm) and sub-central in position (shifted slightly towards the venter, situated 10 mm from the ventral side of the shell wall, 13 mm from the dorsal). The phragmocone has a maximum diameter of 25 mm and expands slowly with an angle of 3°. The convex side of the adoralmost preserved septum shows massive hyposeptal deposits surrounding the siphuncle. In outline, these bilaterally symmetrical deposits resemble a figure '8'; they are more massive ventrally than dorsally. The external surface of the shell is smooth. The adoral phragmocone fragment shows two straight and slightly oblique suture lines spaced 1.8 mm apart (at a corresponding shell diameter 25 mm). The specimen is accompanied by a small Lingulate Brachiopod and the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus.
The initial chamber of MWB S 06765 classified by Aubrechtová et al. as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 differs from Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1 in being smaller in dimensions, less ovoid and less constricted. Hyposeptal cameral deposits are present. The only known Cephalopod from the Ordovician of Bohemia comparable in shape and position of deposits is Orthoceras bonum. However, this species was previously speculated to represent an Actinoceratid or alternatively a Pseudorthoceratid, none of which exhibit the initial chamber morphology described above in MWB S 06765.
Specimen NM L 46565, a juvenile shell, from the Praha-Šárka locality of the Šárka Formation, is identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 3. This specimen is a counterpart of a juvenile shell with only the adoralmost septum preserved; the initial chamber is broken off. Total length is 25 mm. Minimum preserved diameter of the phragmocone is 1.7 mm, the maximum diameter is 4.5 mm; the phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The siphuncle is narrow, 0.7 mm in diameter (at maximum shell diameter) and central in position. The phragmocone expands with an angle of 7°. The external shell surface shows irregular, fine and straight transverse ornamentation; in the adapical and middle parts of the specimen the ornamentation is accentuated and regularly developed.
NM L 46565 has an angle of expansion comparable to Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1 but the former must have had a much smaller initial chamber. In its small size, NM L 46565 resembles Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 but the latter has a lower angle of expansion. Based on the comparisons to Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2, the initial chamber in NM L 46565 probably did not exceed 1.9 mm in diameter.
Two specimens MWB S 06827, and 06828), counterparts of juvenile shell parts from the Volduchy locality of the Šárka Formation are identified as exceed 1.9 mm in diameter. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 4. MWB S 06827 is a counterpart of the embryonic shell including the initial chamber. The length of the specimen is 3.2 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 1.8 mm in diameter. The phragmocone is constricted at a distance of 1.3 mm from the tip of the initial chamber and at 1.5 mm of shell diameter. This constriction is assumed to correspond to the position of the first phragmocone septum; the shape ratio of the initial chamber is then 0.72 and constriction ratio 0.83. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. Longitudinal, faintly sinuous shell ornamentation; it disappears at the adoral part of the specimen where it is replaced by slightly oblique transverse sculpture.
Finally, specimen NM L 59872, an embryonic shell, from the Malé Přílepy locality of the Dobrotivá Formation, is identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 5. This specimen is a counterpart of an embryonic shell. Total length is 3.3 mm. Shell diameter is 1.8 mm along the specimen length; no marked constriction is discernible on the phragmocone. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The external shell surface at its apical part shows fine longitudinal structures, while in the adoral part, transverse lirae are observed.
The size and shape of the initial chamber in NM L 59872 is very similar to that in MWB S 06827 assigned above to Orthoceratida indet. sp. 4. The preservation of both specimens is, however, too fragmentary to allow more precise comparisons and unequivocal taxonomic classification.
Previous studies on the early ontogeny in Ordovician Orthoceratoids have focused on general patterns in the embryonic shell size distribution among individual groups of Cephalopods and trends in the morphology of these shell parts over longer time periods. The size of embryonic shell has been used to estimate egg and hatchling size. In early Palaeozoic Nautiloid Cephalopods, the timing of hatching can be determined using the criteria that apply in the Recent Nautilus (except for the nepionic constriction which is not known in early Palaeozoic Cephalopods with certainty). In contrast, there are varying opinions regarding the recognition of the hatching phase and the size of embryonic shells in Orthoceratoid Cephalopods. For this purpose, changes in septal spacing, apical angle and ornamentation have been used. Previous studies have concluded that Orthoceratoid embryonic shells probably consisted of the initial chamber, one or two phragmocone chambers and the living chamber The view assuming a direct ontogenetic development of early Orthoceratoids is followed by the present authors, as well. An alternative hypothesis supposed that Orthoceratoid embryonic shell had consisted only from the first, sub-sphaerical chamber, while the adjacent cylindrical part of the shell was considered to represent the larval stage.
With the exception of Bactroceras angustisiphonatum and Orthoceras sp., the late Early–Middle Ordovician Orthoceratoid initial chambers are relatively large in dimensions; the morphology of adjacent parts of the shell, including the living chamber, imply the presence of relatively large embryonic shells. In contrast to that, Late Ordovician and especially younger, Silurian, orthoceratoid initial chambers and embryonic shells generally have smaller sizes. This apparent shift in the size of initial chambers and embryonic shells in Orthoceratoids from the Middle Ordovician onwards, have been recorded previously. It has been assumed that this reflects the gradual decreasing of egg and hatchling size and to indicate changes in reproductive strategies (towards larger amounts of smaller juveniles) and life modes (towards planktotrophy and pelagic lifestyles) in Orthoceratoids and their descendants, i.e., Bactritoids, Ammonoids, and Coleoids.
However, two Ordovician Orthoceratoids, Bactroceras angustisiphonatum and Orthoceras sp. contradict the above trend in being considerably smaller in dimensions than other Middle Ordovician Orthoceratoids. In both taxa, this may reflect the shell sizes of stratigraphically early Orthoceratoids. Sea-water temperatures have to be taken into account, as well, and studies on fossil Cephalopods have indicated that the cooling of climates/position in high palaeolatitudes induced an increase in the size of embryonic shells. In contrast, warming of climates/position in lower palaeolatitudes was reportedly accompanied by a decrease in these sizes.
The only initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri previously known was figured by Joachim Barrande in 1868. The initial chamber is rather different in appearance from initial chambers of other Ordovician Orthoceratoids. Based on the collection of eleven additional, newly obtained specimens it can be confirmed that this is not the result of any deformation or growth anomaly: the initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri is sub-sphaerical (bean-shaped in median section), relatively large and short and constricted at the first phragmocone septum. Several well preserved counterparts of initial chambers definitely confirm the absence of a cicatrix, a systematically and phylogenetically important feature. These specimens also indicate that the sculpture of the embryonic and early juvenile shell in Bactroceras is smooth but can also exhibit fine longitudinal or obliquely transverse striae. Unfortunately, Barrande’s original specimen is preserved only as a corroded internal mould and therefore cannot show the character of ornamentation or prove the absence of a cicatrix with certainty.
Two specimens (NM L 10331 and MWB S 06759) preserve the caecum, which is long and tubular, moderately (MWB S 06759) to strongly (NM L 10331) bent laterally and inward. It remains close to the shell wall or in close contact with it throughout its length. The long, inward bent caecum in Bactroceras and also in Archigeisonoceras may have enhanced buoyancy control and migration potential of the hatchlings.
The morphological variability of the initial chamber of Bactroceras is low The angle of expansion changes in earliest ontogeny, the shell diameter at the first septum is slightly larger than that at the second septum. The shell starts to expand regularly only at about the mid-way between the second and third septum (NM L 10331, MWB S 06759). In some Nautiloids and Bactritoids the change of juvenile shell expansion indicates the hatching phase. If the same were true for Bactroceras, then its egg would have been ovoid and c. 3 mm in length.
Another interesting fact is the pronounced difference of apex morphology between the two species of Bactroceras in which the early growth stage is known. Besides the contrasting dimensions, the initial shell of Bactroceras angustisiphonatum is ovoid in shape and less constricted than the sub-sphaerical initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri. Such a difference within a single genus has not yet been documented in exocochleate Cephalopods. This may call into question the congenerity of the two species which are otherwise closely similar in other morphological traits of their shells.
The eighteen specimens studied by Aubrechtová et al. significantly expand the rather sporadic record of the earliest growth stages of Ordovician Orthoceratoids. The initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri, one of the stratigraphically oldest known Orthoceratoids, is now known in twelve specimens in total. It is large and very short, sub-sphaerical (bean-shaped in median section) and constricted at the first phragmocone septum. The absence of the cicatrix can now be definitely confirmed. The dimensions of the specimens point to a low morphological variability in both shape and size of juvenile growth stages of the species. The caecum (observed in the type specimen and one additional specimen) is long, tubular and bent inwards (dorsally). A slight decrease in the angle of expansion of the embryonic shell has been observed halfway between the second and third suture, or at the third suture. This may indicate the boundary between embryonic and post-embryonic stages.
The recently obtained specimen of Bactroceras sp. marks the first confirmed occurrence of this genus in the upper Darriwilian Dobrotivá Formation. The specimen thus fills the gap between verified Middle and Upper Ordovician occurrences of Bactroceras in the Prague Basin.
Bactroceras shows a marked intrageneric difference in the shape and size of initial chamber: in Bactroceras angustisiphonatum the initial chamber is ovoid and 2–2.5 times smaller compared to that in Bactroceras sandbergeri.
Three other orthoceratid specimens described by Aubrechtová et al. are variable in their embryonic shell sizes. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1 with the diameter of 3 mm and height 3.1 mm is the largest initial chamber known from Ordovician Orthoceratids. The initial chamber in Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 is similar in shape to the former species but is one-third smaller; an adoral septum of the phragmocone shows hyposeptal cameral deposits. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 3 differs from Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 in the smaller dimensions of its apical shell part and from MWB S 06765 in having a higher angle of expansion. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 4 from the Šárka Formation and Orthoceratida indet. sp. 5 from the Dobrotivá Formation are very similar in the size and shape of their initial chambers; their incomplete preservation, however, hinders the possibility to determine whether the two specimens represent the same species.
The comparably large-sized Cephalopod embryonic growth stages with voluminous initial chambers described by Aubrechtová et al. from the Darriwilian Stage of Bohemia confirm the presence of a functional phragmocone (i.e., capable of buoyancy regulation) in phylogenetically early Orthoceratoids. The initial chambers and reconstructed embryonic shells are mostly larger than those known from the Late Ordovician and especially Silurian strata. This may be a reflection of previously reported shifts in reproductive strategies and modes of life in early Palaeozoic Orthoceratoid Cephalopods towards gradual decreasing of egg and hatchling sizes, larger amounts of smaller juveniles, juvenile planktotrophy and pelagic lifestyles. Additionally, the influence of palaeoclimatic conditions and sea-water temperatures is implied.
See also...
Eighteen specimens were investigated in this study, sixteen of which originate from the Šárka Formation. NM L 46566 was collected by František Hanuš in the 1930’s at the locality of Praha-Šárka cihelna (brickyard). NM L 46565 originates from the collection of Celda Klouček from the locality of Praha-Šárka. The remaining specimens were recently collected by Ondřej Zicha in the area of the city of Rokycany at the following localities: Mýto (Svatoštěpánský rybník-Teletník; MWB S 06761, 06765), Mýto (Svatoštěpánský rybník-Kařízek; MWB S 06762), Rokycany-Díly (MWB S 06759, 06763), Těškov (MWB S 06760, 06764), and Volduchy (MWB S 06823–06828); one specimen comes from the locality of Praha-Hanspaulka NM L 59577).
Two specimens from the Dobrotivá Formation (NM L 59578, 59872) were found by Ondřej Zicha at localities of Lhotka u Berouna and Malé Přílepy.
All specimens from the Šárka Formation are preserved in 3D in siliceous, originally carbonaceous, nodules. The specimens are mostly preserved as counterparts but internal moulds or their fragments are also present. The specimens are not deformed or recrystallized with the exception of NM L 46566, which is entirely in-filled with brown-orange carbonate crystals. NM L 59578 from the Dobrotivá Formation is preserved 3D in a grey-coloured sandy nodule; NM L 59872 is embedded in a dark-grey silicified nodule.
Measurements were performed using either a handheld calliper or an Olympus SZH10 microscope with an integrated scale (angles of expansion of the shells were not precisely measurable in short fragments). Latex casts were prepared from selected counterparts of specimens. Specimens were coated in ammonium chloride, and photographed with Canon EOS 6D and SONY ILCE-7RM3 digital cameras. The specimen of Bactroceras sandbergeri, NM L 10331, with preserved initial chamber was studied for comparisons.
Thirteen of the new specimens were also referred to the species Bactroceras sandbergeri.
The first of these, MWB S 06759, is a part and counterpart of an embryonic portion of the shell with the initial chamber. The total length of the specimen is 2.7 mm. The subspherical initial chamber (i.e. the first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 2.5 mm in diameter and 0.9 mm in length (shape ratio 0.36). The second phragmocone chamber is 2.1 mm in basal diameter and 1.8 mm in length. The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (constriction ratio 0.84). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The marginal (ventral) siphuncle is weathered out and a cavity is left. The cavity appears at about the mid-length of the initial chamber. The caecum is cylindrical, 0.3 mm in diameter; its apical end clearly bends towards the inside of the initial chamber at about its mid-length. The external surface as shown by the latex cast of the counterpart is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by another Orthoceratoid shell ornamented with transverse lirae, an indeterminate Hyolith, the Trilobite Ormathops and the Brachiopod Euorthisina sp
Apical shell parts of the Orthoceratoid Bactroceras sandbergeri, Middle Ordovician, lower Darriwilian Stage, Šárka Formation, Czech Republic. (A) MWB S 06759, Rokycany-Díly, internal mould in ventral view (A₁), with accompanying Trilobite Ormatops sp., Brachiopod Euorthisina sp., and indeterminate Hyolith; detail (A₂), note the decrease of apical angle at second phragmocone chamber; latex cast of counterpart in ventral view (A₃). (B) MWB S 06764, Těškov, internal mould in lateral view, venter on right hand-side (initial chamber bent towards dorsum), initial and second phragmocone chamber preserved as counterpart. (C) MWB S 06760, Těškov, latex casts of both sides of counterparts (C₁), (C₂), note suspicious surface structures. (D) NM L 59577, Praha-Hanspaulka, latex cast of counterpart. Aubrechtová et al. (2020).
The second specimen, MWB S 06760, is a counterpart of a shell and the third septum of the phragmocone showing the position of the siphuncle. The specimen shows an imprint of the initial chamber. The total length of the specimen is 5.2 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) was bean- shaped in median section, 2.5 mm in diameter and 1.2 mm in length (shape ratio 0.48). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2.2 mm, constriction ratio 0.88). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The specimen is accompanied by the Hyolith Bactrotheca teres and other indeterminate invertebrate fragments.
The third specimen, MWB S 06761, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell. The total length of the specimen is 13.1 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 2.2 mm in diameter and 1.1 mm in length (shape ratio 0.5). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2 mm, constriction ratio 0.91). The phragmocone has a maximum diameter of 2.5 mm and expands very slowly (angle of expansion 2°). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The external surface is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by a Hyolith and other indeterminate invertebrate fragments.
The fourth specimen, MWB S 06762, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell. The total length of the specimen is 20 mm. The initial chamber is bean-shaped in median section, 2.5 mm in diameter and 1.6 mm in length (shape ratio 0.64). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2.3 mm, constriction ratio 0.92). The phragmocone expands very slowly. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The external surface is smooth.
Apical shell of the Orthoceratoid Bactroceras sandbergeri; Middle Ordovician, lower Darriwilian Stage, Šárka Formation, Czech Republic. (A) MWB S 06761, Mýto-Svatoštěpánský rybník, latex cast of one of counterparts in lateral view, note fine, obliquely transverse surface ornamentation. (B) MWB S 06762, Mýto-Svatoštěpánský rybník, counterpart (B₁) and its latex cast (B₂), in lateral view (initial chamber bent towards dorsum). (C) MWB S 06763, Rokycany-Díly, internal mould in lateral view, single (adoral-most) phragmocone chamber showing ventrally situated siphuncle (C₁), latex cast of the second counterpart (C₂). Aubrechtová et al. (2020).
The fifth specimen, MWB S 06763, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell with one phragmocone chamber preserved adorally. The total length of the specimen is 10.4 mm. The initial chamber is bean-shaped in median section, 2 mm in dorso-ventral diameter and 1.3 mm in length (shape ratio 0.65). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 1.8 mm, constriction ratio 0.9). The phragmocone has a maximum dorso-ventral diameter of 2.3 mm and expands very slowly. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The septum of the adoralmost phragmocone chamber displays the submarginal (subventral) siphuncle, which has a circular cross-section and a diameter of 0.25 mm. The external shell surface is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus, the Trilobite Pricyclopyge cf. binodosa and an indeterminate Bivalve.
The sixth specimen, MWB S 06764, is a fragment of a counterpart of a juvenile shell with one phragmocone chamber preserved adorally. The total length of the specimen is 3.5 mm. The initial chamber is bean-shaped in median section, very short, 2.6 mm in dorso-ventral diameter and 1.4 mm in length (shape ratio 0.54). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber was 2.2 mm, constriction ratio 0.85). The phragmocone has a maximum dorso-ventral diameter of 2.2 mm and expands very slowly; it is circular in cross-section. The length of the adoralmost phragmocone chamber is 1.2 mm. The siphuncle is narrow, submarginal (ventral) with a circular cross-section. The external shell surface is smooth. The specimen is accompanied by the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus.
The seventh specimen, NM L 59577, is a counterpart of an embryonic shell with the initial chamber. The adoral part of the shell is very slightly bent. The total length of the specimen 4.5 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 2.0 mm in diameter and 1.2 mm in length (shape ratio 0.6). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the second phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 1.7 mm, constriction ratio 0.85). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. No shell ornamentation is discernible. The nodule containing this specimen also yielded the rare Graptolite Dichograptus? leptotheca.
The eigth specimen, MWB S 06823, represents the third phragmocone chamber (estimated based on the shell diameter and length of this chamber) and the adapical part of the living chamber. The phragmocone has a minimum dorsoventral diameter of 1.8 mm, a minimum lateral diameter of 1.6 mm and expands very slowly; it is slightly compressed in cross-section. The length of the third phragmocone chamber is 2.7 mm. The siphuncle is narrow, submarginal (ventral) with a circular cross-section; its diameter at the foramen of the adapical septum is 0.25 mm. The specimen is accompanied by undetermined Hyoliths and the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus.
Apical and juvenile shell parts of Orthoceratid Cephalopods; Middle Ordovician, Darriwilian Stage, Šárka and Dobrotivá formations, Czech Republic. (A) Bactroceras sandbergeri, MWB S 06823, Volduchy, third phragmocone chamber (estimated based on shell diameter) and adjacent part of body chamber. (B) Orthoceratida indet. sp. 4, MWB S 06827, Volduchy, counterpart of initial chamber and adjacent part of phragmocone and one corroded phragmocone septum; note longitudinal striae. (C) Orthoceratida indet sp. 5, NM L 59872, Malé Přílepy, counterpart (C₁), latext cast (C₂); note longitudinal striae. Aubrechtová et al. (2020).
The three remaining specimens MWB S 06824–06826 from the locality Volduchy are juvenile shell fragments that morphologically correspond to the above described specimens. However, their preservation hinders precise measurements.
MWB S 06759, 06763, and 06764 are shell fragments of larger individuals as indicated by the absence of living chambers. By contrast, specimen MWB S 06823 probably represents the shell of an early juvenile individual. The rest of the specimens (counterparts) do not show any internal structures and therefore can represent both complete shells of freshly hatched individuals, or adapical parts of later growth stages.
The specimens unequivocally belong to Bactroceras sandbergeri because they exhibit short, bean-shaped in median section, rather large and constricted initial chambers. These characters correspond in all aspects to the only apex previously known from the species.The only difference concerns the caecum, which is slightly more curved in MWB S 06759 than in the original specimen.
In Bactroceras the apicalmost chamber is known also in Bactroceras angustisiphonatum, where it is, however, much smaller in size (1.3 mm in height, 1 mm in diameter, shape ratio 1.3), less constricted (constriction ratio 0.95) and more ovoid in shape.
Of all known Ordovician Orthoceratoids, the shape of the initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri is most similar to that of Orthoceras sp. The latter is, however, much smaller in diameter, the caecum is much shorter and the siphuncle has a ventro-central position. Compared to Bactroceras sandbergeri, the initial chamber of Archigeisonoceras sp. is smaller and only very slightly constricted; the caecum is bent inwards and relatively long but expands inside the initial chamber.
One specimen, NM L 59578, is referred to Bactroceras sp., i.e. assigned to the genus Bactroceras, but not a species. This specimen is a fragment of an adapical part of a juvenile phragmocone with visible concave side of one septum. The length of the specimen is 3.5 mm. The phragmocone has a maximum diameter of 2.5 mm and expands at a very low angle (which cannot be precisely measured). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The septal foramina of the single visible septum is circular in cross-section, c. 0.1 mm in diameter and submarginal in position. The external surface of the shell is smooth.
The narrow, submarginal siphuncle of NM L 59578 indicates the specimen should be assigned to the genus Bactroceras. However, the preservation of the specimen does not permit determination to the species level.
NM L 59578 represents the first record of Bactroceras from the late Darriwilian Dobrotivá Formation of the Prague Basin.
Specimen NM L 46566 is considered to have come from an unknown Orthoceratid species, identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1. The specimen is a part and a counterpart of a phragmocone with the initial chamber. Adapical third of the phragmocone is longitudinally broken off and infilled with a brownish carbonate mineral; the broken portion was reconstructed using a latex cast prepared from the counterpart. The total length of the specimen is 46.8 mm. A weakly sinuous line along the contact of the fossil and the surrounding rock indicates the presence of a low annulation on the surface of the shell. The surface is, however, slightly corroded and does not show any other ornamentation. The initial chamber is egg-shaped, very slightly asymmetric from one side, 3 mm in diameter and 3.1 mm in length (shape ratio c. 1). The diameter of the initial chamber exceeds that of the adjacent phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 2.6 mm, constriction ratio 0.87). The first, straight and directly transverse, suture is faintly indicated. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section with a maximum diameter of c. 7 mm and expands with an angle of 6°.
The initial chamber of the specimen stands out among other apical shell parts known from Ordovician Orthoceratids in its large size reaching 3 mm in diameter and 3.1 mm in length. It may resemble the initial chamber described in Arionoceras?, which is ovoid in shape; the latter is, however, smaller in dimensions, more distinctly constricted and has a greater angle of expansion (13°).
The Bohemian specimen more likely belongs to one of the Middle Ordovician Orthoceratid species described by Joachim Barrande, in which early ontogenetic stages are not yet known. Unfortunately, the collection of Joachim Barrande contains either fragmentary material, or specimens representing only late ontogenetic stages. Moreover, the preservation of the specimen studied here does not show the character of the siphuncle and ornamentation is only slightly indicated, which prevents the specimen from being more precisely identified.
Apical shell parts of three indeterminate Orthoceratid Cephalopods; Middle Ordovician, lower Darriwilian Stage, Šárka Formation, Czech Republic. (A) Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1, NM L 46566, Praha-Šárka cihelna (brickyard), part (A₁) and latex cast of the counterpart (A₂), detail of latex cast (A₃), note large size of egg-shaped initial chamber. (B) Orthoceratida indet. sp. 3, NM L 46565, Praha-Šárka, single (adoralmost) phragmocone chamber showing centrally situated siphuncle (B₁), counterpart with one adoral septum (B₂), latex cast of counterpart showing transverse surface ornamentation (B₃). (C) Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2, MWB S 06765, Mýto-Svatoštěpánský rybník, detail of adoralmost septum with hyposeptal cameral deposits around the subcentral siphuncle (C₁), the second counterpart (C₂), note the absence of cameral deposits at septum situated more apically than in (C₁), latex cast of the previous associated with Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus. Aubrechtová et al. (2020).
Another specimen, MWB S 06765, is considered to belong to another unknown species, identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2. This specimen consists of two counterparts of a phragmocone composed of two dislocated fragments. In each of the two counterparts there is one septum preserved. The rest of the shell was reconstructed from a latex cast. Total combined length is 15.3 mm (apical fragment 9.1 mm and adoral fragment 6.2 mm). The initial chamber is eggshaped, 2 mm in dorso-ventral diameter and 2 mm in length (shape ratio 1). Its diameter very slightly exceeds that of the adjacent phragmocone chamber (basal diameter of the second phragmocone chamber is 1.9 mm, constriction 0.95). The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The siphuncle is 0.25 mm in diameter (corresponding shell diameter 23 mm) and sub-central in position (shifted slightly towards the venter, situated 10 mm from the ventral side of the shell wall, 13 mm from the dorsal). The phragmocone has a maximum diameter of 25 mm and expands slowly with an angle of 3°. The convex side of the adoralmost preserved septum shows massive hyposeptal deposits surrounding the siphuncle. In outline, these bilaterally symmetrical deposits resemble a figure '8'; they are more massive ventrally than dorsally. The external surface of the shell is smooth. The adoral phragmocone fragment shows two straight and slightly oblique suture lines spaced 1.8 mm apart (at a corresponding shell diameter 25 mm). The specimen is accompanied by a small Lingulate Brachiopod and the Bellerophontid Tropidodiscus pusillus.
The initial chamber of MWB S 06765 classified by Aubrechtová et al. as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 differs from Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1 in being smaller in dimensions, less ovoid and less constricted. Hyposeptal cameral deposits are present. The only known Cephalopod from the Ordovician of Bohemia comparable in shape and position of deposits is Orthoceras bonum. However, this species was previously speculated to represent an Actinoceratid or alternatively a Pseudorthoceratid, none of which exhibit the initial chamber morphology described above in MWB S 06765.
Specimen NM L 46565, a juvenile shell, from the Praha-Šárka locality of the Šárka Formation, is identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 3. This specimen is a counterpart of a juvenile shell with only the adoralmost septum preserved; the initial chamber is broken off. Total length is 25 mm. Minimum preserved diameter of the phragmocone is 1.7 mm, the maximum diameter is 4.5 mm; the phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The siphuncle is narrow, 0.7 mm in diameter (at maximum shell diameter) and central in position. The phragmocone expands with an angle of 7°. The external shell surface shows irregular, fine and straight transverse ornamentation; in the adapical and middle parts of the specimen the ornamentation is accentuated and regularly developed.
NM L 46565 has an angle of expansion comparable to Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1 but the former must have had a much smaller initial chamber. In its small size, NM L 46565 resembles Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 but the latter has a lower angle of expansion. Based on the comparisons to Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2, the initial chamber in NM L 46565 probably did not exceed 1.9 mm in diameter.
Two specimens MWB S 06827, and 06828), counterparts of juvenile shell parts from the Volduchy locality of the Šárka Formation are identified as exceed 1.9 mm in diameter. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 4. MWB S 06827 is a counterpart of the embryonic shell including the initial chamber. The length of the specimen is 3.2 mm. The initial chamber (first phragmocone chamber) is bean-shaped in median section, 1.8 mm in diameter. The phragmocone is constricted at a distance of 1.3 mm from the tip of the initial chamber and at 1.5 mm of shell diameter. This constriction is assumed to correspond to the position of the first phragmocone septum; the shape ratio of the initial chamber is then 0.72 and constriction ratio 0.83. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. Longitudinal, faintly sinuous shell ornamentation; it disappears at the adoral part of the specimen where it is replaced by slightly oblique transverse sculpture.
Finally, specimen NM L 59872, an embryonic shell, from the Malé Přílepy locality of the Dobrotivá Formation, is identified as Orthoceratida indet. sp. 5. This specimen is a counterpart of an embryonic shell. Total length is 3.3 mm. Shell diameter is 1.8 mm along the specimen length; no marked constriction is discernible on the phragmocone. The phragmocone is circular in cross-section. The external shell surface at its apical part shows fine longitudinal structures, while in the adoral part, transverse lirae are observed.
The size and shape of the initial chamber in NM L 59872 is very similar to that in MWB S 06827 assigned above to Orthoceratida indet. sp. 4. The preservation of both specimens is, however, too fragmentary to allow more precise comparisons and unequivocal taxonomic classification.
Previous studies on the early ontogeny in Ordovician Orthoceratoids have focused on general patterns in the embryonic shell size distribution among individual groups of Cephalopods and trends in the morphology of these shell parts over longer time periods. The size of embryonic shell has been used to estimate egg and hatchling size. In early Palaeozoic Nautiloid Cephalopods, the timing of hatching can be determined using the criteria that apply in the Recent Nautilus (except for the nepionic constriction which is not known in early Palaeozoic Cephalopods with certainty). In contrast, there are varying opinions regarding the recognition of the hatching phase and the size of embryonic shells in Orthoceratoid Cephalopods. For this purpose, changes in septal spacing, apical angle and ornamentation have been used. Previous studies have concluded that Orthoceratoid embryonic shells probably consisted of the initial chamber, one or two phragmocone chambers and the living chamber The view assuming a direct ontogenetic development of early Orthoceratoids is followed by the present authors, as well. An alternative hypothesis supposed that Orthoceratoid embryonic shell had consisted only from the first, sub-sphaerical chamber, while the adjacent cylindrical part of the shell was considered to represent the larval stage.
With the exception of Bactroceras angustisiphonatum and Orthoceras sp., the late Early–Middle Ordovician Orthoceratoid initial chambers are relatively large in dimensions; the morphology of adjacent parts of the shell, including the living chamber, imply the presence of relatively large embryonic shells. In contrast to that, Late Ordovician and especially younger, Silurian, orthoceratoid initial chambers and embryonic shells generally have smaller sizes. This apparent shift in the size of initial chambers and embryonic shells in Orthoceratoids from the Middle Ordovician onwards, have been recorded previously. It has been assumed that this reflects the gradual decreasing of egg and hatchling size and to indicate changes in reproductive strategies (towards larger amounts of smaller juveniles) and life modes (towards planktotrophy and pelagic lifestyles) in Orthoceratoids and their descendants, i.e., Bactritoids, Ammonoids, and Coleoids.
Drawings of known embryonic shells with initial chambers of Ordovician Orthoceratoids. Dotted lines indicate the assumed position of the siphuncle in Arionoceras? sp. and Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2. In Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2, note a sketch of hyposeptal cameral deposits. The stratigraphic position of Bactroceras angustisiphonatum and Arionoceras? sp. is either uppermost Lower Ordovician, or lowermost Middle Ordovician. Orthoceratidae gen. et sp. indet B is likely to be conspecific with Transorthoceras osmundsbergense. Aubrechtová et al. (2020).
However, two Ordovician Orthoceratoids, Bactroceras angustisiphonatum and Orthoceras sp. contradict the above trend in being considerably smaller in dimensions than other Middle Ordovician Orthoceratoids. In both taxa, this may reflect the shell sizes of stratigraphically early Orthoceratoids. Sea-water temperatures have to be taken into account, as well, and studies on fossil Cephalopods have indicated that the cooling of climates/position in high palaeolatitudes induced an increase in the size of embryonic shells. In contrast, warming of climates/position in lower palaeolatitudes was reportedly accompanied by a decrease in these sizes.
The only initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri previously known was figured by Joachim Barrande in 1868. The initial chamber is rather different in appearance from initial chambers of other Ordovician Orthoceratoids. Based on the collection of eleven additional, newly obtained specimens it can be confirmed that this is not the result of any deformation or growth anomaly: the initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri is sub-sphaerical (bean-shaped in median section), relatively large and short and constricted at the first phragmocone septum. Several well preserved counterparts of initial chambers definitely confirm the absence of a cicatrix, a systematically and phylogenetically important feature. These specimens also indicate that the sculpture of the embryonic and early juvenile shell in Bactroceras is smooth but can also exhibit fine longitudinal or obliquely transverse striae. Unfortunately, Barrande’s original specimen is preserved only as a corroded internal mould and therefore cannot show the character of ornamentation or prove the absence of a cicatrix with certainty.
Two specimens (NM L 10331 and MWB S 06759) preserve the caecum, which is long and tubular, moderately (MWB S 06759) to strongly (NM L 10331) bent laterally and inward. It remains close to the shell wall or in close contact with it throughout its length. The long, inward bent caecum in Bactroceras and also in Archigeisonoceras may have enhanced buoyancy control and migration potential of the hatchlings.
The morphological variability of the initial chamber of Bactroceras is low The angle of expansion changes in earliest ontogeny, the shell diameter at the first septum is slightly larger than that at the second septum. The shell starts to expand regularly only at about the mid-way between the second and third septum (NM L 10331, MWB S 06759). In some Nautiloids and Bactritoids the change of juvenile shell expansion indicates the hatching phase. If the same were true for Bactroceras, then its egg would have been ovoid and c. 3 mm in length.
Another interesting fact is the pronounced difference of apex morphology between the two species of Bactroceras in which the early growth stage is known. Besides the contrasting dimensions, the initial shell of Bactroceras angustisiphonatum is ovoid in shape and less constricted than the sub-sphaerical initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri. Such a difference within a single genus has not yet been documented in exocochleate Cephalopods. This may call into question the congenerity of the two species which are otherwise closely similar in other morphological traits of their shells.
The eighteen specimens studied by Aubrechtová et al. significantly expand the rather sporadic record of the earliest growth stages of Ordovician Orthoceratoids. The initial chamber of Bactroceras sandbergeri, one of the stratigraphically oldest known Orthoceratoids, is now known in twelve specimens in total. It is large and very short, sub-sphaerical (bean-shaped in median section) and constricted at the first phragmocone septum. The absence of the cicatrix can now be definitely confirmed. The dimensions of the specimens point to a low morphological variability in both shape and size of juvenile growth stages of the species. The caecum (observed in the type specimen and one additional specimen) is long, tubular and bent inwards (dorsally). A slight decrease in the angle of expansion of the embryonic shell has been observed halfway between the second and third suture, or at the third suture. This may indicate the boundary between embryonic and post-embryonic stages.
The recently obtained specimen of Bactroceras sp. marks the first confirmed occurrence of this genus in the upper Darriwilian Dobrotivá Formation. The specimen thus fills the gap between verified Middle and Upper Ordovician occurrences of Bactroceras in the Prague Basin.
Bactroceras shows a marked intrageneric difference in the shape and size of initial chamber: in Bactroceras angustisiphonatum the initial chamber is ovoid and 2–2.5 times smaller compared to that in Bactroceras sandbergeri.
Three other orthoceratid specimens described by Aubrechtová et al. are variable in their embryonic shell sizes. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 1 with the diameter of 3 mm and height 3.1 mm is the largest initial chamber known from Ordovician Orthoceratids. The initial chamber in Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 is similar in shape to the former species but is one-third smaller; an adoral septum of the phragmocone shows hyposeptal cameral deposits. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 3 differs from Orthoceratida indet. sp. 2 in the smaller dimensions of its apical shell part and from MWB S 06765 in having a higher angle of expansion. Orthoceratida indet. sp. 4 from the Šárka Formation and Orthoceratida indet. sp. 5 from the Dobrotivá Formation are very similar in the size and shape of their initial chambers; their incomplete preservation, however, hinders the possibility to determine whether the two specimens represent the same species.
The comparably large-sized Cephalopod embryonic growth stages with voluminous initial chambers described by Aubrechtová et al. from the Darriwilian Stage of Bohemia confirm the presence of a functional phragmocone (i.e., capable of buoyancy regulation) in phylogenetically early Orthoceratoids. The initial chambers and reconstructed embryonic shells are mostly larger than those known from the Late Ordovician and especially Silurian strata. This may be a reflection of previously reported shifts in reproductive strategies and modes of life in early Palaeozoic Orthoceratoid Cephalopods towards gradual decreasing of egg and hatchling sizes, larger amounts of smaller juveniles, juvenile planktotrophy and pelagic lifestyles. Additionally, the influence of palaeoclimatic conditions and sea-water temperatures is implied.
See also...
Follow Sciency Thoughts on Facebook.