Showing posts with label Magdalenian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Magdalenian. Show all posts

Saturday, 7 January 2023

Understanding the message behind Europe's Upper Palaeolithic cave art.

Prior to about 37 000 years ago, cave art in Europe consisted largely of patterns of hand-prints, rectangles, and dots. After this time, a wealth of engraved and painted images swept across the continent, depicting the Animals of the Late Pleistocene with a realism that still impresses modern artists. Almost all of these artworks depict large herbivorous Animals, thought to have been important food sources for hunters on the Eurasian Steppes. In most cases it is easily possible to tell what species is being depicted, and even what time of year the image was portraying. The paintings on the walls of the Lascaux Cave in southwest France show a sequence of rutting Animals which can be interpreted as an ethological calendar (calendar of Animal behaviour), and at other sites the presence of Cervids (Deer) with antlers, and the aggressive postures of these Animals, have been interpreted as depiction of a particular season.

However, this cave art does not just depict Animals, alongside these images are frequent abstract marks, mostly dots and lines, but including other shapes such as 'Y's. These marks are usually either directly adjacent to the Animal images, or actually overlie them, suggesting a strong connection between the two. Similar marks have been found carved onto bones, dating from the onset of the European Upper Palaeolithic (roughly equivalent to the African Middle Stone Age) onwards, and are generally thought to have had a recording function. It has been generally assumed that such marks are numeric, and probably recording periods of time, but their exact message has remained unclear. 

Previous studies have found that 66% of the Animal depictions in Upper Palaeolithic European cave art are associated with other symbols, although these vary in form, and probably convey a variety of messages. It is also likely, given the long chronological range and wide geographical area over which these symbols are found, that more than one form of symbolic recording is present. 

In a paper published in the Cambridge Archaeological Journal on 5 January 2023, independent researchers Bennett Bacon, Azadeh Khatiri, and James Palmer, together with Tony Freeth of the Department of Mechanical Engineering at University College London, Paul Pettitt of the Department of Archaeology at the University of Durham, and Robert Kentridge of the Department of Psychology at the University of Durham and the Canadian Institute for Advanced Research programme in Brain, Mind and Consciousness, focus on two clear and simple patterns found in many of these depictions: Animals found associated with rows of dots and/or lines (which are presumed to be functionally the same) and branching 'Y' symbols. 

These symbols are found throughout the European Upper Palaeolithic, although most common from the later portion of this period, possibly implying that they became more common over time. Bennet et al. consider the meaning of the Animal depictions to be unambiguous, but consider the lines, dots, and 'Y' symbols to be potentially interpretable, and related to the ethology of the Animals they are found close to. The basis for this assumption is that the dots and lines in these sequences represent numbers, and that the combination of numbers and recognisable Animals gives the basis for deciphering messages tens of thousands of years ago.

Examples of animal depictions associated with sequences of dots/lines. (a) Aurochs: Lascaux, late period; (b) Aurochs: La Pasiega, late; (c) Horse: Chauvet, late (we differ in opinion with the Chauvet team, for whom it would be early); (d) Horse: Mayenne-Sciences, early; (e) Red Deer: Lascaux, late; (f) Salmon: Abri du Poisson, early; (g) Salmon (?): Pindal, late; (h) Mammoth: Pindal, early. Bacon et al. (2022).

It is now generally accepted that the regular marks left by Upper Palaeolithic peoples represent a form of counting, and therefore the storage of information outside of the brain. The processing of numbers can be done in several ways; by subitisation, or simply recognising small groups of objects at a glance (e.g. six tins in a box), by cardinality, or counting objects (twenty sheep in a field), or by ordinality, being able to place objects within a sequence (the third house in a row). Experimentally these have been shown to be distinct skills, carried out in different parts of the brain, and children have been shown to develop these skills in order as they develop, starting with subitisation and progressing to ordinality. 

In 1991, Alexander Marshack suggested that the dots and lines seen in Upper Palaeolithic art were numbers, most likely representing periods of time. In his view, each dot or line was likely to represent a day, with the sequences of pictures they were associated with being lunar calendars. The lunar calendar theory failed to win many supporters within the academic community, but the concept of the representations as a simple way of recording events outside the mind did gain wider acceptance. 

The grouping of engraved marks on bones and antlers from the Upper Palaeolithic has led to the conclusion that these marks were being used to store information, and that this information was most likely numeric. This has in turn led to the suggestion by cognitive archaeologist Karenleigh Overmann  that once Humans had begun to collect numerical data, it was almost inevitable that they would apply this to time, and in particular the seasons, important phenomena in the lives of people so closely dependent on nature.

The sequences of dots and lines found adjacent to Palaeolithic Animal images fit the same criteria for representing numbers as the carvings on bones and antlers, and are consistently arranged in lines horizontal to the orientation of the Animal images (which are often on ceilings). These sequences vary in length, but appear to have been recording numbers using the additive principle, where an extra mark represents an increase by one (as in the Roman numerals, I, II, III; or the Chinese 一, 二, 三).

In the 1990s archaeologist Carole Fritz assembled a database of 90 symbols used on portable objects associated with the Late Palaeolithic Magdalenian Culture, collected from the Dordogne and Pyranees, and including linear marks, dashes, angular signs, arc shapes, broken lines, dots, various impact marks and combinations and repetitions thereof. These symbols were used consistently at sites associated with the Magdalenian Culture, with no discernible variations over space and time. Based upon this, Fritz concluded that these marks represented a method of storing information recognised across the Magdalenian Culture, although the exact meaning implied remained obscure.

Hunting appears to have been an important source of nutrition to Upper Palaeolithic peoples, with the most important prey species being Horses, Bovids, Cervids, Caprids, Proboscideans, Birds, and aquatic Animals. Modern populations of these Animals show strong seasonal patterns of behaviour, with cycles of mating and birthing, and seasonal migrations in the spring and autumn. During this seasonal cycle, many of these Animals shift between large and small groups, and are present on different parts of the landscape.

Zooarchaeological studies have revealed a similar seasonality in the behaviour of these Animals during the Pleistocene, and it seems likely that a knowledge of migration patterns and breeding cycles would have been key information to Upper Palaeolithic hunters dependent on these Animals for survival. As such, it is unsurprising that these Animals were a central preoccupation for these people, and that images of them dominate their art. Furthermore, at sites such as Lascaux Cave depict these Animals in such detail that their pelage, hair, antler growth, gregarious and aggressive behaviour and other indications of rutting can be used to show that their breeding behaviour was also of great interest. Many of the Animal images at Lascaux are associated with symbols; for example a row of swimming Stags, generally interpreted as an autumn migration scene, is accompanied by a row of seven red dots, while a mating scene with male and female Aurochs in their summer coat is marked with four black dots. At a scene from the slightly later Font de Gaume Cave two Reindeer stags are depicted with locked antlers, and marked with a set of eight dots.

Bacon et al. accept the premise that the sequences of dots and lines associated with the Upper Palaeolithic Animal images are saying something about the Animals in the images with which they are associated. Furthermore, they accept that these are abstract representations, rather than parts of the images, noting that several different taxa are consistently annotated with the same number of dots, but on different parts of their anatomies. Given this consistency, they also accept that the message conveyed by the dots is numerical in nature, being either cardinal or ordinal.

Working from this, they assume that the objective was to convey some form of useful numeric information about specific prey Animals to future readers. Given this, it seems unlikely that they were recording the number of Animals sighted, the time at which they were sighted, or even the number of Animals killed. It is likely, however, that they would have wanted to record information about migrations, times when Animals could be relied upon to form aggregations, and times when Animals were most vulnerable to attacks by hunters (i.e. mating and birthing). Working from these assumptions, Bacon et al. propose that the timing of such events is the most logical numerical information to have been juxtaposed with the Animal images.

If Upper Palaeolithic people were able to record numbers using the additive principle, then it is quite likely that the rows of dots or lines seen on their art represent amounts of time. Furthermore, the number of dots or lines associated with an Animal image is never particularly high (and never higher than thirteen), so if each dot or line represents a single unit of time, then that unit is almost certainly a lunar month, since this is one of the few units which would have been obvious to pre-agricultural people. Based upon this, Bacon et al. believe that the dots and lines present in Upper Palaeolithic images represent lunar months, presenting information about the behaviour of Animals on a seasonal calendar. 

If this is correct, then the calendar being used by these people must have had an established beginning; a time of year against which the tallies could be counted, giving the people using it a point to count from. Most historical calendars have their roots in astronomical observations, counting from the solstices and equinoxes. These give accurate dating systems usable by agriculturalists, but are difficult to observe, and likely to have been of limited use to Palaeolithic hunters. Rather, these people lived in a world dominated by meteorological events, and seasonal cycles in temperature and the behaviour of Plants and Animals. One seasonal event which Bacon et al. believe would have been hard for Palaeolithic peoples to miss would have been the annual spring thaw. This is widely referred to using the French term bonne saison by zooarchaeologists, marking a period when rivers unfroze, snow melted, and the world began to turn green. This would not have occurred everywhere at the same time, with spring coming several weeks earlier in southern Europe than in the north, but would have provided a useful starting point for a yearly calendar used by people needing to track the migrations and mating habits of Animals, but not exchange accurate date information with distant communities. 

One of the problems for peoples wanting to record time in the ancient world was that the solar year cannot be divided into an exact number of lunar months (there are approximately 12.37 lunar months in one solar year). This led to the development of a variety of complex calendars, with periodic adjustments being made to bring the solar and lunar cycles into alignment. None of this is likely to have mattered much to Upper Palaeolithic peoples counting from the bonne saison, who could have just counted the lunar months from each spring thaw into the depths of winter, when it would have become irrelevant. 

Bacon et al. therefore theorise that the sequences of dots and lines in Upper Palaeolithic art represent lunar months after the bonne saison. Therefore, if an Animal is represented along with a sequence of three dots, then the intent was to imply some important feature of that Animal's life cycle happened three months after the spring thaw. This is technically an interval calendar, recording that events happened a certain period after the bon saison, rather than a true calendar recording accurate dates.

Furthermore, Bacon et al. note that many of the sequences contain a 'Y' symbol in the midst of a series of dots or lines, which they believe represents a significant event in the life cycle of these Animals, and reason must be one of four possible annual occurrences, spring migration, mating, birthing, or autumn migration. 

The 'Y' symbol is one of the most commonly depicted symbols in Upper Palaeolithic art, and therefore presumably has an important meaning. Bacon et al. note that the position of this symbol within sequences varies between Animal taxa, but remains constant for each taxon, implying that it is carrying species specific data, and that that data appears to be ordinal in nature, within an ordinal sequence. Thus the total number of symbols potentially records one piece of information, with the position of the 'Y' symbol conveying a second. Bacon et al. further propose that, given the known biology of the Animals involved, the 'Y' symbol is most likely to represent birthing.

In order to test this hypothesis Bacon et al. compiled a database of Animal symbols with associated symbol sequences, and compared these to known data on the reproduction and migration of their modern relatives, and information about Pleistocene Animals established by previous zooarchaeological studies. Having eliminated any dubious or ambivalent sequences from the record, Bacon et al. were left with 256 sequences containing a 'Y' symbol and 606 sequences which did not.  The majority of these sequences came from France and Spain, although some came from further east. Chronologically, the images span the whole of the Late Upper Palaeolithic, although the majority come from the end of this period. 

Bacon et al. initially divided their data into two chronological sections, the Early and Middle Upper Palaeolithic Aurignacian and Gravettian cultures, and the Late Upper Palaeolithic Solutrian and Magdalenian cultures, but surprisingly no difference could be found between these datasets, suggesting that, contrary to expectations, the same data-recording system seems to have persisted in Europe for over 20 000 years. 

For the sake of convenience, Bacon et al. sorted some of the Animals depicted into groups, such as Cervids, Caprids, Birds, and Fish, while others were retained as separate species, i.e. Bison, Aurochs, Horses, Mammoths and Rhinos. Other species, such as Snakes and Wolverines, were present, but in very low numbers, and were excluded from the dataset, as were images of Humans.

In order to make the comparison, Bacon et al. converted the expected birthing season for the Animals into months relative to the Pleistocene bonne saison. Thus, assuming the bonne saison started around the start of May, the birthing season for European Bison, typically August, should be 3 or 4. Such a calendar is necessarily approximate, given that it is based upon seasonal events which might themselves vary from year to year, and will certainly vary regionally.

Bacon et al.'s prediction was that the 'Y' symbols related to each Animal group should be clustered, rather than randomly distributed throughout the sequences, and that these clusters should correspond to the predicted birthing seasons of the Animals, adjusted to an ordinal calendar rooted at the bonne saison. Since this should be different for the different groups, the position of the 'Y' symbol in the sequence should also vary between groups.

This prediction proved to be true for the majority of the groups, with the 'Y' symbol being both consistent and coinciding with the predicted birthing season for Aurochs, Bison, Horses, Fand Mammoths, and less clear but still matching the prediction for Cervids. Only Caprids failed to match the prediction, with no clear pattern observable in the data for this group. No correlation could be made between the position of the 'Y' symbols and the predicted times of mating or migration. However, the observed total number of marks correlated to the predicted mating season for Aurochs, Bison, Horses, Mammoths, and probably Cervids.

The two non-Mammalian groups, Birds and Fish, showed slightly different patterns, with the 'Y' correlating with mating and the end of the line with hatching for Birds, and the 'Y' correlating with the spring migration and the end of the line with hatching in Fish; in both cases the sequence relates to the appearance of a food source.

Bacon et al.'s data provides strong statistical evidence for a correlation between the position of a 'Y' symbol in a sequence associated with an image of an Animal, and the birthing season of that Animal, as calculated on an interval lunar calendar rooted in the Pleistocene bonne saison. It also provides weaker statistical support for the total number of marks representing the mating season of the same Animals. 

The idea of Upper Palaeolithic peoples in Europe using a form of numeric notation using notches, lines, and other marks has been accepted for some time, and is no longer really controversial. Based upon this, it has also been generally assumed that other marks used by these people were recording some form of information, although the exact nature of this information has, until now, remained unclear. 

Bacon et al. propose that the symbols associated with the (unambivalent) Animal images relates directly to the biology and behaviour of those Animals, providing a key to understanding the Upper Palaeolithic notation system. This is based on the assumption that the position of a particular mark, the 'Y' symbol, within a sequence of simpler marks (dots or lines), represents a key event in the life cycle of these organisms, in this instance the birthing season, something supported by a statistical analysis of the data.

This means that these Upper Palaeolithic people had a means of preserving information which could be read back after thousands of years, by people who might have quite different languages, but understood the common notation system (we know little of the languages spoken in the Upper Palaeolithic, but they are unlikely to have remained constant for tens of thousands of years). The widespread use of this system over long periods of time and a wide geographical area suggests that it was important to record this information in a way that went beyond oral traditions (although these are likely to have also been used).

The symbols represent more than a simple tally, and Bacon et al. propose that they represent the development of a simple calendar, based upon meteorological events and the biology of important prey Animals. This would predate by many thousands of years any previously known calendar or writing system.

It is far from clear how widely the interpretation of this data would have been understood in the communities which produced it. Objects, such as bones or antlers, with tallies on them are widely known from this period, and would presumably have been present in domestic environments, carried by members of the community. However, the cave art was typically placed in deep cave environments, where it was potentially not seen by the whole community, and may have been restricted to a small number of people.

Bacon et al. do not argue that their interpretation is exclusive of the artworks having had other purposes, aesthetic or ritual, nor do they claim to have unravelled all of the meaning behind the symbols (other symbols are present in the cave art, which they have not included in this study). Furthermore, they do not assert that this notation system was used by all peoples present in Europe throughout the Upper Palaeolithic, and acknowledge that there are plenty of instances of Upper Palaeolithic art in which Animals are depicted without the presence of additional symbols of any kind.

They do however, believe they have uncovered a method of storing data about the behaviour of important prey Animals, which was used in parts of western and central Europe for a period which lasted from about 37 000 years ago to about 13 000 years ago. In this interpretation, the individual images do not represent individual Animals, but are instead representative of entire species, and the behaviour of these species as experienced by the creators of the art. 

The rows of symbols and position of marks within them represent a simple syntax combining linear and ordinal numbers to record and communicate information, a form of intellectual abstraction, something which is considered to a key achievement of modern Humans (Upper Palaeolithic peoples are universally accepted as fully Modern Humans). This ability to record a combination of information derived the behaviour of Animals, number-based information, seasonal meteorology, and lunar months, therefore represents a significant intellectual achievement. This provided a system to preserve this information that went beyond oral tradition, and enabled the comparison of data from multiple years, presumably enabling the people who collected it to make estimations about variations in natural phenomena, something hard to do with purely oral records.

This raises the question of whether this system could genuinely be called writing. The system does seem to be able to deal with discrete quantities, i.e. using numbers to say something about the Animals they are associated with, rather than just counting the numbers. Furthermore, the use of placement to determine the value of the 'Y' symbol is a precursor of the use of place to show the value of a number (as in 1, 10, 100), something previously assumed to have been a Sumerian invention. It could even be considered that the 'Y' symbol represents a verb, 'to give birth', although this is less than clear, it could simply be a noun such as  'birth' or 'birthplace'.

The common modern use of the term language implies that it has a phonetic connection to a spoken language, generally that used by the writer. This is again thought to have originated in ancient Sumer, Mesopotamia, around 3300 BC, when a system comprising a mixture of pictograms and abstract numerical symbols first appeared. These system evolved into Cuneiform, which is considered to be a script rather than a language (in the sense that the modern English and French languages are written in Latin script). A form of record-keeping using small tokens is known to have been used in the Near East in the Neolithic, during the tenth millennium BC, with the system evolving over time and being widespread in the region by the sixth millennium BC. By the fourth millennium BC these tokens appeared to have taken other, non-numeric functions, something which evolved further into the Cuneiform script of Uruk-era Sumer. 

Bacon et al. postulate that the European Upper Palaeolithic system actually conveys more information than the first Mesopotamian scripts, in that in relates the behaviour of wild Animals to a meteorologically derived calendar, whereas the earliest Mesopotamian records appear to have just recorded quantities of items. Based upon this, they argue that this system can justifiably be called a script. However, they note that the system gives no indication as to how the people using it would have described the Animals depicted, the Moon or its phases, or the bonne saison, although they do assume that these people would have been able to describe all these things orally.

The European Upper Palaeolithic recording system appears to contain no grammatical syntax, which would justify its description as a true written language, but does seem to be recording data at least as well as the proto-Cuneiform script of ancient Sumer (although, unlike the Sumerian records, this system could not be described as 'administrative documents'). 

For this reason Bacon et al. do not press the claim that this system should be seen as a language (something they see as potentially controversial, and at best semantic), but a form of proto-writing forming a step between a simple tallying system and a true writing system. They are aware that this claim is likely to be contested, and that others in the field are likely to come up with other ideas about what this system should be called. 

For the time being they restrict themselves to describing the system as a form of proto-writing, conveying a phrenological/meteorological calendar, although they welcome debate on the subject. However this system should be described, it clearly represents a system of symbolic record-keeping dating from tens of thousands of years before the earliest Sumerian writing system, making it a highly significant discovery.

See also...

Follow Sciency Thoughts on Facebook.

Follow Sciency Thoughts on Twitter.


Tuesday, 13 December 2022

Successful genotyping of two end-Pleistocene, Palaeolithic, individuals from Britain.

The warming period after the Last Glacial Maximum saw radical shifts in the distribution of Animals and Plants in Europe, and with it an expansion of both Human populations and their cultural diversity. However, while the importance of this interval is well understood, we have relatively little evidence from this time.

Improvements in genotyping ancient remains have enabled scientists to study ever older populations in recent years, with the ability now including individuals from the Late Pleistocene of Europe. Such studied have exposed shifts in genetic patterns within populations, exposing Human migrations that were not clear from the conventional archaeological record. One of the more notable of these newly discovered population shifts occurred between the Last Glacial Maximum, approximately 23 000 years ago, and the onset of the Holocene Epoch, which is placed at 11 700 years before the present. During this shift, populations belonging the 'Goyet Q2' ancestry group, named after the 15 090-year-old Goyet Q2 individual from Belgium were replaced with populations belonging to the 'Villabruna' ancestry group, named after the approximately 14 010-year-old Villabruna individual from Italy. 

The Goyet Q2 ancestry group has been shown to include the roughly 18 700-year-old El Mirón individual from Spain, as well as other individuals associated with the ancient Magdalenian Culture, which is found at archaeological sites dated to between about 20 500 years ago and about 14 000 years ago across Europe. It has been suggested that this group represents individuals descended from a population from a southwest European glacial refugia, which spread across Europe as the glaciers covering the continent retreated.

The Villabruna ancestry group, also known as the Western Hunter Gatherers, includes a range of individuals found across Europe, dating to between about 14 000 and about 7000 years ago. This genotype group has been associated with individuals from archaeological sites associated with Epigravettian, Azilian/Federmesser, Epipalaeolithic and Mesolithic cultures. While this ancestry group is considered to be entirely European in distribution, all of the individuals assigned to it also show genetic affinities to modern Near Eastern populations. The expansion of this population has been linked to the onset of the rapid warming phase known as the Late Glacial Interstadial, about 14 650 years ago, as well as the cultural transition that saw the Magdalenian/Late Upper Palaeolithic culture replaced by the Azilian/Federmesser-Gruppen/Final Palaeolithic culture, and has been suggested to have been linked to a new group of people migrating into Europe during this warming phase.

Curiously, individuals of mixed Goyet Q2/Villabruna ancestry are also known from southern Europe, first appearing about 18 700 years ago, with the El Mirón individual. This has led to the suggestion that European Humans were confined to a few isolated refugia in the southern part of the continent during the Last Glacial Maximum, but that there was some genetic and cultural exchange between these refugia. However, the fact that people with unadmixed Goyet Q2 genotypes were living in Europe as late as 14 000 years ago suggests that this interchange was very limited, and that high levels of isolation persisted through the Last Glacial Maximum and into the Late Glacial. 

There is also evidence of people living north of the Alps during the Last Glacial Maximum, migrating from east to west, and remaining in ice-marginal environments. These people have been linked to the Magdalenian culture, which would fit with the model of the Goyet Q2 ancestry group being Magdalenian hunter gatherers, who retreated into northern Europe as the climate warmed, possibly following herds of Reindeer or Horses. South of the Alps, species such as Red Deer persisted throughout the Last Glacial Maximum and Late Glacial, creating a wider range of ecological opportunities for Human hunter gatherers, and thereby allowing greater population admixture in this region. 

The northwesternmost limit of this post-glacial expansion reached Britain, of which two thirds were covered with ice during the Last Glacial Maximum. Britain deglaciated rapidly, leading to accelerated ecological and environmental changes. By 19 000 years ago the ice sheet which had covered much of Britain and Ireland was melting rapidly, with England and Wales being free of ice by about 16 000 years ago. Reindeer are known to have been present in southwest England by 17 000 years ago, living in a landscape dominated by open steppe–tundra vegetation. The earliest evidence for Human occupation in post-glacial Britain comes from about 15 500 years ago, with populations probably established in several areas by the onset of the Late Glacial Interstadial, 14 650 years ago. Current dating suggests that Britain was repopulated after the nearby Paris Basin and the Belgian Ardennes, possibly by people expanding from those regions. The Magdalenian toolset used by these earliest colonisers was similar to that used in the northern Netherlands and the lowlands of northern Germany and Poland. Nevertheless, the amount of archaeological material we have from Britain during this period is extremely limited, restricting the the inferences that can be made about this population.

Genetic analysis techniques have been applied to Mesolithic, Neolithic, and Bronze Age individuals from Britain, but not, to date, to individuals from the Palaeolithic. This is, at least in part, due to the extremely limited nature of the Palaeolithic skeletal record, with such material only having been recovered from only six sites across Britain. The position of this population, at the extreme fringe of the post-Late Glacial Maximum European expansion, means that they can potentially tell us a great deal about the movement of Human populations during this time. All Mesolithic British individuals genotyped to date have belonged to the Villabrauna population, suggesting that this group had reached the northwesternment fringe of Europe by about 10 500 years ago. It is not clear, however, just when these people arrived in Britain, or what the genetic affinities of the Palaeolithic populations of Britain were. The apparent link between the Goyet 2 ancestry group and the Magdalenian culture leads to the hypothesis that these earliest settlers in Britain belonged to that group, but this has not, to date, been tested.

In a paper published in the journal Nature Ecology and Evolution on 24 October 2022, a team of scientists led by Sophy Charlton of the School of Archaeology at the University of Oxford and the Natural History Museum, Selina Brace, also of the Natural History Museum, and Mateja Hajdinjak of the Ancient Genomics Laboratory a the Francis Crick Institute, present the results of analysis of the DNA of two individuals from the Late Palaeolithic of England and Wales, and discuss the implications of their results. 

The first individual included in the study came from Kendrick’s Cave, which is located on Great Orme’s Head, a limestone massif in Llandudno, North Wales. This cave yielded four individuals, three adults and a child, which have been radiocarbon dated to between 11 990 and 11 905 years before the present. As well as the Human remains, the site yielded a range of artefacts which have been linked to the Magdalenian culture, including the proximal portion of a broken blade with en éperon butt preparation, a cut-marked Bovine bone dated to about 14 500 years before the present, a decorated Horse mandible dated to about 12 900 years before the present, and beads made from the teeth of Brown Bear,  Aurochs and Red Deer. 

The first molar from the mandible of the one individual (Kendricks_074, the skeleton dated to 11 905 years before the present) from Kendrick's Cave was subjected to DNA analysis. In addition, samples a were taken from all four Kendrick's Cave skeletons for  carbon and nitrogen isotope analysis. This isotopic analysis provided insight into the diet of the individuals, which suggested a diet rich resources obtained from marine or freshwater sources. This is known to have an impact on radiocarbon dating, leading to a revised date for Kendricks_074 of 13 770 to 13 390 years before the present, and a revised occupancy period for the cave, starting between 16 410 and 14 070 years before the present, and ending between 13 730 and 13 140 years ago. 

The second individual included in the study comes from Gough’s Cave, part of a large cave system situated in Cheddar Gorge in Somerset, southwest England. Gough's Cave is one of the best known Palaeolithic sites in Britain, with a large assemblage of both stone tools and Animal remains. Occupancy at the site is thought to have begun at the beginning of the Late Glacial Interstadial, as temperatures in the region began to rise rapidly. The technology present comprises a mixture of late Magdalenian and early Federmesser-Gruppen tools. At least six Palaeolithic Humans were buried here (one child, two adolescents, and three adults), as well as a later, Mesolithic individual (famous as 'Cheddar Man'). Two of the Palaeolithic Humans have been directly radiocarbon dated, and all show signs of considerable postmortem modification, interpreted as signs of cannibalism, and the modification of skulls to manufacture drinking cups. Based upon the radiocarbon dates obtained and the technologies present in the cave, the Palaeolithic occupation of Gough's Cave is thought to have lasted from about 14 840 to about 14 680 years ago - less than 200 years.

One of the human skulls carefully shaped into a cup or bowl by the people who lived at Gough's Cave 14,700 years ago. Natural History Museum.

Charlton et al. obtained sample DNA from a Human temporal bone (PVM 96544) from Gough's Cave, as well as carrying out new radiocarbon dating on this and other material from the site. The new radiocarbon data was used to obtain a revised occupation period for the cave, starting between 15 070 and 14 850 years ago, and ending between 14 960 and 14 610 years ago. This new dating suggests that occupation began before the onset of the Late Glacial Interstadial warming.

None of the Human material from Gough's and Kendrick's caves shows overlapping dates. However, the modified Bovid bone from Kendrick's Cave does overlap chronologically with the Human remains from Gough's Cave, suggesting that both sites were occupied simultaneously for at least some of the period. The two individuals included in the study were separated in time by at least 600 years (assuming no seafood was consumed in either party's diet), but this could potentially be as high as 840-1200 years.

Charlton et al. recovered 15 497 unique fragments of mitochondrial DNA and 30 587 614 unique fragments of nuclear DNA from the Gough's Cave individual, representing about 23% of the total genome. From the Kendrick's Cave individual they recovered 9702 unique fragments of mitochondrial DNA, and 29 326 159 unique fragments of nuclear DNA, representing about 18% of the total genome. 

ecause mitochondrial DNA is found in the mitochondria, organelles outside the cell nucleus, it is passed directly from mother to child without being sexually recombined each generation, enabling precise estimations of when individuals shared common ancestors, at least through the female line, forming a mitochondrial haplogroup. It is also possible to trace direct ancestry through the male line, using DNA from the Y chromosome, which is passed directly from father to son without sexual recombination, forming a Y-chromosome haplogroup.

The mitochondrial DNA recovered was sufficient to assign both individuals to mitochondrial haplogroups. The Gough's Cave individual belongs to the U8a haplogroup, while the Kendrick's Cave individual belongs to the U5a2 haplogroup. The U8a haplogroup has not been previously recorded in Britain, but is the haplogroup to which the Goyet Q2 individual belongs, as well as individuals associated with Magdalenian artefacts at several archaeological sites, including those at Hohle Fels and Brillenhöhle in Germany. The U5 haplogroup has been recorded at several Mesolithic sites in Britain, including one from Kent's Cavern who shares the U5a2 haplogroup variant. 

It was also possible to determine the sex of both individuals, with the Gough's Cave individual being female, and the Kendrick's Cave individual being male. Interestingly, the Kendrick's Cave individual had been recorded as 'male' in the original description of the skeleton, although no reason was ever given for this.

The nuclear genome of the Gough's Cave individual is close to that of the Goyet Q2 individual, placing that individual within the Goyet Q2 ancestry group. The Kendrick's Cave individual clusters with individuals from the Villabrauna ancestry group, including Mesolithic individuals from Britain; to date all Mesolithic individuals from Britain have belonged exclusively to the Villabrauna ancestry group, with the exception of 'Cheddar Man' (who was also recovered from Gough's Cave), who's ancestry was 84.6% Villabrauna and 15.4% Goyet Q2.

Location, genetic ancestry and Accelerator Mass Spectrometry date of End Palaeolithic European individuals. (a) Map indicating the location of Pleistocene sites and the genetic ancestry of individuals analysed from them. (b) North Greenland Ice Core Project ice core δ¹⁸O values and event stratigraphy, genetic ancestry and date  of individuals (95% confidence interval of calibrated radiocarbon dates for directly dated Humans). The Gough’s Cave and Höhle Fels specimens are not directly dated and therefore for Höhle Fels specimen the age range shown is the 95% confidence interval of calibrated radiocarbon dates from bones recovered from the same area/context. For the Gough’s Cave specimen, the age range shown is the Bayesian modelled site occupation start and end dates based on Accelerator Mass Spectrometry dating of the Human remains and Human modified faunal remains. Charlton et al. (2022).

The genetic and radiocarbon dating evidence obtained by Charlton et al. indicates that two genetically distinct populations of Humans were present in Britain during the Late Glacial period. The individual sampled from Gough's Cave showed clear affinity to the Goyet Q2 ancestry group, while the Kendrick's Cave individual clearly grouped with the Villabrauna group. Neither individual showed any genetic admixture, although the Gough's Cave tool assemblage does appear to be of mixed origins, containing both late Magdalenian and early Federmesser-Gruppen technologies. Furthermore, the only lithic tool from Kendrick's Cave clearly fits with the Magdalenian technology, while the individual sampled from the same location belonged to the Villabrauna ancestry group, typically associated with the Epigravettian and Azilian/Federmesser technologies. However, the decorative objects from Kendrick's Cave are similar to items from Federmesser-Gruppen sites in Europe. This may indicate that the boundaries between cultures were not so rigid at this time as generally assumed, or even that the populations at both sites contained a mixture of Humans from both cultures, but this has not been captured by sampling only one individual from each group. What the study does clearly demonstrate is that the Villabrauna ancestry group had clearly reached Britain by the Late Glacial, though whether there is a continuity with Holocene populations belonging to the same group, or whether they represent a subsequent second migration to the island after the Younger Dryas cooling event (between 12 900 and 11 700 years ago) is unclear.

The Younger Dryas represents a significant interlude between the temperate climate of the Late Glacial and that of the Holocene. During this interval ice sheets spread southward from Scotland, and Reindeer become the most common Animal remains found in caves in southwest Britain. At the moment, there are no Human remains from Britain which can be assigned to the Younger Dryas interval by radiocarbon dating, though it is unclear if this represents a lack of (discovered) preserved material or an actual absence of Humans. If there really were no Humans present in Britain during this period, then the subsequent Villabrauna populations must represent a second migration of that group into Britain. Furthermore, whilst the Villabrauna ancestry group appears to be dominant in Britain during the Mesolithic, at least one individual is known to be of mixed heritage, possibly suggesting that the cultural changes that led to the Mesolithic involved a degree of blending between groups.

Britain is not the only area where both Late Palaeolithic European populations are present, the same has been observed in Iberia, where individuals with mixed heritage are present at El Mirón in Spain from about 18 770 years ago. However, while both populations have been detected in Britain, no trace of genetic admixture has (yet) been discovered in the Palaeolithic, which may indicate a more dramatic population turnover.

These two Late Palaeolithic populations from Britain lived somewhere between 600 and 12 000 years apart, and, as well as being genetically different, appear to have had different diets, based upon stable isotope analysis of skeletal material from the two sites. They also appear to have had quite different approaches to the handling of the dead, with modification of remains and possible cannibalism present at Gough's Cave but not at Kendrick's Cave. This does suggest that a considerable degree of cultural, as well as genetic, turnover was occurring during a time of known climatic and ecological shifts, again, something seen elsewhere in Europe.

The very limited supply of skeletal material from the Late Pleistocene of Britain, along with the rate at which DNA degrades in deceased individuals, means that there will never be a very clear picture of the genetic make-up of these populations. However, a limited amount of information is not zero, and Charlton et al. have demonstrated that useful studies can be done on Late Pleistocene genetics in Britain, raising the potential that we yet learn more about this subject.

See also...

Follow Sciency Thoughts on Facebook.

Follow Sciency Thoughts on Twitter.